HMRC R&D enquiry defense & support
HMRC R&D enquiry?
InnoFund is ready to defend your claim.
When HMRC questions an R&D claim, the response needs tax expertise and a clear account of the science or technology. InnoFund brings Simba Mareverwa’s industry-leading enquiry experience together with scientists, engineers and financial specialists from our purpose-built enquiries team to assess the claim, build the evidence and manage the next step.
- groupsSenior-led case strategy
- scienceOur own technical specialists
- verified_userClaims prepared elsewhere
Experience behind the response
Tax expertise.
Scientific depth.
Received an enquiry from HMRC?
Understand the questions.
Take control of the response.
A compliance check can arrive before or after an R&D credit has been paid. HMRC may be checking the qualifying work, the expenditure or the way the claim was submitted. The first task is to establish what the letter means, which accounting period it concerns and what needs attention now.
We support businesses whose claims were prepared by InnoFund, another adviser or an internal team. We can lead the enquiry or work alongside your accountant, with a named senior specialist responsible for the agreed work.
- Identify the correspondence
- A prompt to review a claim, an enquiry notice and a disputed decision each call for a different response.
- Protect the relevant dates
- We identify response and appeal deadlines from the actual correspondence. Flag any urgent date when contacting us.
- Recover the filed position
- We establish exactly what was claimed and what HMRC has already received, including replies from previous advisers.
- Agree the engagement
- You receive a clear scope, responsibilities and fee basis before appointing us.
Why specialist R&D support matters
The science behind the claim.
The judgement behind the response.
R&D enquiries can turn on whether a problem represented a genuine uncertainty in a field of science or technology. Our specialists work with the people who carried out your project to examine that question, test the reasoning and connect it to the financial claim.
Scientific understanding
Explain the uncertainty precisely.
Dr Jack Brent brings a PhD in Materials Science, chemistry and tax qualifications, and previous enquiry-defence experience. Relevant scientists help examine the baseline, intended advance, trials and results.
Engineering and sector knowledge
Get close to the work.
Richard Hine brings practical manufacturing and engineering experience, including HMRC defence meetings. Dr Malcom Sande adds doctorate-level electronic engineering expertise.
Financial and tax analysis
Make the evidence reconcile.
Our tax and financial specialists test scheme conditions, contracts, qualifying expenditure and apportionments, linking the technical work to the return, claim calculations and underlying accounts.
Enquiry strategy
Present one coherent position.
Simba Mareverwa leads the strategy, bringing chartered accountancy, dispute leadership and accredited mediation experience to the correspondence and available resolution routes.
We work with your competent professionals, who understand your projects, and select specialists from within our team to support with relevant industry knowledge.
The people behind your enquiry
A team matched to the questions.
Simba leads our enquiry and dispute work. Scientists, engineers and financial specialists contribute around the issues in your claim, working with your own project and finance teams. Legal or additional external expertise is coordinated where the case requires it.
What HMRC may be testing
Find the issue.
Build the right evidence.
An R&D enquiry may focus on a technical point, a calculation or several connected questions. We separate those issues so the response addresses HMRC’s actual concerns under the rules for the accounting period being checked.
The advance and baseline
What knowledge or capability already existed in the field, what advance the project sought and why the work went beyond established practice.
Uncertainty and the work undertaken
Why a competent professional could not readily deduce the answer, and how investigation, testing, design changes or unsuccessful routes addressed the uncertainty.
Project boundaries
When qualifying R&D began and ended, which activities supported it, and how those activities fit within the wider commercial project.
Expenditure and apportionment
How eligible costs were identified, allocated and reconciled, with an evidenced basis for estimates and the scheme conditions that applied.
Contracts and entitlement
The impact of customer and supplier arrangements, funding and where work was carried out. The treatment depends on the relevant scheme and period.
The claim as a whole
Whether the return, computation, additional information and explanations present a consistent account, and what any proposed adjustment or penalty actually concerns.
The evidence we start with
A clear account of the work.
A traceable basis for the costs.
Start with the latest letter and any deadline. We then agree a focused request for the claim file, project evidence and financial records. You can contact us while records are still being gathered.
HMRC’s guidance recognises proportionate records and, in appropriate cases, later explanations from competent professionals. We assess what is available, identify gaps and explain how they affect the position.
- mail
HMRC’s letters and your replies
The full correspondence history, current requests, notices, decisions and response dates.
- description
The claim as filed
The Company Tax Return, computation, technical report and Additional Information Form where required.
- science
Project records
Designs, lab notes, test results, prototypes, development records, meeting notes and relevant correspondence.
- groups
The people who know the project
Your competent professionals’ experience and reasoned account of the baseline, advance, uncertainties and work.
- calculate
The financial workings
Cost schedules, payroll, invoices, payment records and the basis used to allocate expenditure to qualifying activity.
- contract
Contracts and funding
Customer and supplier agreements, subcontracting arrangements and grant or other funding terms relevant to the claim.
What you can expect
Assess the position.
Prepare the response.
Stay accountable.
You should understand the case being presented and the decisions that affect it. Our work is organised around a clear issue list, evidence linked to each question and an agreed plan for correspondence and next steps.
- 01
A case and deadline assessment
Review the letter, filed claim and correspondence. Identify the procedural stage, urgent actions, amount at issue and support you need.
- 02
A candid technical and financial review
Work with your project and finance teams to test eligibility, evidence and costs. Explain strengths, gaps and any position that needs correcting.
- 03
An organised response
Prepare clear answers, a supporting evidence schedule and the relevant technical and tax reasoning. Agree the material with your team before submission.
- 04
Representation and meeting preparation
Within the agreed engagement and HMRC authority, manage correspondence, prepare your people for discussions and keep you informed of outstanding questions.
- 05
A documented next step
Explain HMRC’s conclusions and the options at each decision point. Where needed, assess review, ADR or appeal and agree any additional specialist work.
Support shaped around the case
A first letter.
An established enquiry.
A fresh assessment.
We work with business owners, finance teams, accountants and other advisers. The starting point can be a new compliance check, an unresolved technical disagreement or a decision that needs prompt assessment.
A claim prepared elsewhere
Bring us the existing file
We assess the original claim and previous replies, establish what can be supported and explain a practical route forward.
An accountant or internal team
Add the expertise you need
Commission a focused technical review or coordinated enquiry support while your established advisers stay involved.
A stalled or disputed position
Reassess the unresolved issues
Review HMRC’s concerns, the evidence and available procedural routes, with a clear view of the work and decisions ahead.
An InnoFund full-service claim
Check your existing support
We check your original engagement to confirm the enquiry support available and explain any additional work and fees. Discovery assessments and Tax Tribunal work require a separate engagement. Read our terms.
Senior responsibility
Led by Simba.
Grounded in the facts.
Simba Mareverwa is a chartered accountant and accredited mediator whose published career record includes defending more than 260 HMRC enquiries. During ten years at Leyton, he became Head of Tax Compliance and HMRC Dispute Resolution and a UK director.
That experience informs the enquiry strategy, the handling of technical disagreements and the assessment of resolution routes. You receive a considered view of the evidence and a clear explanation of the decisions ahead, including when additional legal or other specialist input is appropriate.
- personA named senior lead
- fact_checkEvidence linked to the issues
- forumClear decisions at each stage
Client experience
Trusted when an R&D claim was challenged.
Sigma Polymers describes its experience of InnoFund’s support with an R&D claim rejection and subsequent appeal.

Simba and his team know the system and minefield of appeals etc. They always kept me fully informed and "went the extra mile." …
R&D enquiry support, explained
Questions when HMRC writes.
Understand the practical support, the team and what happens after the first conversation.
Discuss your R&D enquiry arrow_outwardCan you help if another adviser prepared our R&D claim? add
Yes. We can assess a claim prepared by another adviser or your own team, including an enquiry already underway. We first review the filed position, correspondence, current deadlines and evidence, then agree the appropriate scope and responsibilities.
Is an R&D enquiry different from a general HMRC dispute? add
An R&D enquiry uses the wider HMRC compliance framework, with additional scientific, technological and relief-specific cost questions. A dispute arises when the parties disagree. Our HMRC disputes guide explains the stages and available routes.
Can HMRC check a claim after the credit has been paid? add
Yes. HMRC can enquire after payment within the applicable statutory rules. We check the accounting period, filing and amendment history, and correspondence to establish the position.
Who supplies the technical explanation? add
We work with the competent professionals who understand your project. Relevant scientists and engineers from our team help test and present the baseline, advance, uncertainty and supporting work. Their role is matched to the subject and evidence needed.
What if we have gaps in the project records? add
We assess the records you have and speak to the relevant people. HMRC’s guidance recognises proportionate evidence and allows later explanations in appropriate cases. We explain what the available evidence supports and how any gaps affect the response.
Is enquiry support already included in our InnoFund engagement? add
We check the engagement that applies to your claim to confirm the enquiry support available and explain any additional work and fees. Discovery assessments and Tax Tribunal work require a separate engagement.
Can you help with a decision, penalty or stalled enquiry? add
We can assess the decision or unresolved issues and advise on the relevant options within the agreed engagement, including review, ADR or appeal and coordination with legal specialists where required. Response and appeal dates must be protected throughout.
How long will the enquiry take? add
The issues, available evidence, correspondence and HMRC’s response affect the timetable. We set out the immediate work and dependencies, update you as the case develops and agree the next step at each decision point.
Your next step
Bring the letter.
Let’s understand the case.
Tell us which R&D claim HMRC is checking, what has been requested and when a response is due. We will identify the immediate priorities and the expertise needed to assess the position. Flag an urgent deadline when booking, as a consultation booking does not extend it.
- schedule30 minutesA focused first conversation
- verifiedExpert guidanceTechnical, tax and commercial context
- handshakeCommitment freeA clear next step, without obligation
