The short answer
An R&D enquiry is a specialist Corporation Tax compliance check. HMRC may examine the science or technology behind the claim, the qualifying costs, or both. A dispute develops when the company and HMRC disagree. Start with the letter, identify its status and deadline, then build the response around the evidence and procedure that apply. Decisions, statutory review, ADR and appeals each have their own requirements.
What is the difference between an HMRC enquiry and a dispute?
An HMRC enquiry is a check of a return, claim or tax position. HMRC asks questions and examines evidence to establish whether the correct tax has been paid or relief claimed. A dispute develops when the company and HMRC disagree about facts, eligibility, calculations or the application of the rules. That disagreement can arise while an enquiry is still open.
HMRC dispute resolution describes the work of resolving those disagreements. Depending on the stage, this can involve further evidence, correspondence, a statutory review, Alternative Dispute Resolution (ADR) or an appeal to the independent tax tribunal. The letter you have received determines the immediate response and the dates that matter. HMRC explains compliance checks.
Received a letter about an R&D claim?
Keep the complete letter and note its response date. Our R&D enquiry support team can assess the questions, the filed claim and the evidence needed for the next step, including where another adviser prepared the claim.
How does an R&D enquiry differ from other HMRC disputes?
An R&D enquiry is a specialist Corporation Tax compliance check. The same wider framework of information requests, decisions and challenge routes applies, while the subject matter requires a detailed understanding of science or technology and the R&D relief rules.
| Question | General HMRC enquiry or dispute | R&D enquiry |
|---|---|---|
| What is being checked? | A tax return, transaction, calculation or claim for relief. | Whether the work and expenditure satisfy the R&D scheme applying to the accounting period. |
| What evidence matters? | The records and legal analysis relevant to the disputed tax treatment. | Scientific or technological explanations, project records, competent-professional evidence and qualifying-cost workings. |
| Who contributes? | Directors, finance teams and the relevant tax or other specialists. | Those people together with professionals who understand the project’s scientific or technological field. |
| How can it be resolved? | Evidence, agreement and the applicable review, ADR or appeal routes. | Those routes, supported by a coherent technical and financial case addressing the specific R&D questions. |
For example, a materials project may require an explanation of the knowledge available at the outset, the performance that established methods could achieve, and why a competent professional in the relevant field could not readily deduce how to achieve the intended improvement. The finance records then need to show which expenditure relates to that qualifying work. This illustrative example shows why scientific understanding and tax analysis need to work together. Read the official R&D definition.
Why does HMRC send letters about R&D claims?
R&D relief is claimed through Corporation Tax self-assessment. HMRC checks claims to establish whether the company is entitled to the relief and whether the amount is correct. Its published approach includes risk assessment and random checks. Questions can concern the project, the calculation, the information submitted or several aspects together. Selection for a check does not establish its outcome.
HMRC can enquire after processing a claim or paying a credit, within the applicable statutory rules. Payment therefore needs to be understood alongside the enquiry position. Previous claims and an adviser’s involvement also leave the company responsible for the facts and figures in its return. HMRC’s published compliance approach and R&D claim-handling practice.
What kind of HMRC letter have you received?
Read the wording, legal basis, accounting period and requested action. Similar-looking letters can have different effects. A response date for information and a statutory appeal deadline serve different purposes.
| Correspondence | What it may mean | Your next step |
|---|---|---|
| Prompt or educational letter | HMRC asks you to review a claim or consider whether a correction is needed. | Check the claim against the concerns and follow the letter’s instructions. |
| Enquiry notice and questions | HMRC has opened a formal check and wants explanations or records. | Confirm the scope, response date and people needed to answer. |
| Statutory information notice | HMRC uses formal powers to require specified information or documents. | Check the requirements, safeguards and any available challenge route promptly. |
| Decision, closure notice or assessment | HMRC has formalised its conclusion or a change to the tax position. | Identify any appealable decision and protect the stated challenge deadline. |
| Penalty notice | HMRC has made a separate decision about a penalty. | Review its grounds, calculation and appeal rights as well as the underlying tax. |
Ask the officer to clarify an uncertain request. If you need more time, contact HMRC promptly and obtain agreement. Formal notices carry specific requirements and safeguards. HMRC’s information-notice factsheet.
What should you do first?
Build a reliable starting file
- Keep the letter, attachments and earlier correspondence together.
- Record response, appeal and payment dates separately.
- Confirm the company, accounting period, relief and projects under review.
- Secure the submitted return, computation, Additional Information Form where applicable, report and workings.
- Preserve project and financial records, including relevant emails and test results.
- Involve the people who understand the work and agree who controls the response.
- Confirm the authority HMRC needs before a new adviser represents the company.
A change of adviser or a consultation booking does not extend a deadline. Use the named officer’s contact instructions for an existing enquiry. Our contacting HMRC guide explains the wider contact and agent-authorisation routes.
What must the technical evidence explain?
The starting point is the field of science or technology. Explain the overall knowledge or capability available in the relevant field when the project began, the advance sought, and the uncertainty that a competent professional could not readily resolve. Then show the work undertaken to overcome it and where the qualifying activities began and ended. A commercial project can contain qualifying R&D alongside routine work.
A competent professional needs relevant expertise in that field. Their opinion should explain the reasoning behind the claim, supported by their qualifications or experience and knowledge of the work. A scientist or engineer advising on the enquiry can help test that explanation, working with the company’s people who know the project. HMRC’s competent-professional guidance.
Useful evidence can include plans, designs, calculations, trial results, failed approaches, meeting notes and correspondence. Explain what each record demonstrates. HMRC allows qualifying work to be identified retrospectively and says a detailed later explanation may be acceptable in some cases. Where records are limited, explain the gaps and the basis of the account accurately. HMRC’s record-keeping guidance.
For more background, read our explanation of scientific or technological uncertainty.
How should the financial response support the technical case?
Trace claimed expenditure to the qualifying activities, relevant accounting records and applicable cost rules. Payroll, invoices, contracts, payment evidence and allocation workings can all matter. Explain how staff time or shared costs were apportioned and why that method is reasonable.
The accounting period determines the scheme and rules to examine. Earlier SME and RDEC claims can differ from merged-scheme and enhanced R&D intensive support claims for periods beginning on or after 1 April 2024. Contracted work, subsidies, overseas activity and entitlement to claim require particular care. HMRC’s qualifying-cost guidance.
Organise the response by HMRC’s questions, with numbered supporting records. Make clear which facts are agreed, which assumptions need correcting and which points remain disputed. This lets the officer follow the technical explanation through to the figures. Our R&D tax relief guide explains the underlying claim framework.
What happens next, and how does an enquiry end?
HMRC may ask follow-up questions, request further documents or discuss the work with the company’s competent professionals. Keep an issue list and a record of replies, agreed facts and outstanding actions. The time needed depends on the questions, available evidence and progress with HMRC.
An enquiry can conclude with the claim accepted, adjusted or disallowed. A Corporation Tax enquiry normally ends through a closure notice stating HMRC’s conclusions and any necessary amendment, or through a contract settlement. Consider the tax, repayment and interest consequences together with any challenge rights. HMRC’s guidance on concluding enquiries.
The deadline for opening an enquiry differs from the time needed to complete it. Filing history, group status, amendments and other statutory powers can affect the position. If an enquiry has stalled, a tribunal application for a closure direction may be available after assessing HMRC’s grounds for continuing. Enquiry opening rules and closure applications.
How do appeal and statutory review work?
For an appealable Corporation Tax decision, appeal to HMRC first. Identify the decision, the points disputed and the reasons, with the correct figures and supporting information where appropriate. The deadline is usually 30 days from the decision letter. Check the actual notice and act promptly if a date is close or has passed. HMRC’s appeal guidance.
Following a direct-tax appeal, a statutory review can examine the decision. It is carried out by an HMRC officer from a different team who was uninvolved in making it. Reviews usually take 45 days, subject to the applicable arrangements. The result can uphold, vary or cancel the decision. Tribunal notification following review is usually due within 30 days of the conclusion letter. Statutory review guidance.
Keep procedural dates visible
Continuing correspondence, an ADR application or a complaint does not protect an appeal deadline. Review offers and tribunal notifications also have their own requirements. Record each stage and its date.
When can ADR or the tax tribunal help?
ADR uses a trained HMRC mediator to help the company and case officer address factual disagreement, misunderstandings or stalled communication. It can help identify the evidence needed and narrow unresolved issues. HMRC considers suitability case by case, and the mediator facilitates discussion without deciding the dispute.
ADR can be available during an open enquiry. After an appealable Corporation Tax decision, first appeal to HMRC. Once HMRC has accepted the appeal, ADR can be requested before a review is offered. Once HMRC offers a review, its ADR guidance requires a tribunal appeal and acknowledgement, either after completing an accepted review or after declining the offer. The sequence matters, so check the current requirements and preserve the appeal and tribunal dates throughout. HMRC’s ADR eligibility and timing guidance.
The First-tier Tribunal is independent of HMRC and can determine an eligible tax appeal. Proceedings involve directions, evidence and formal procedural obligations. The team may need technical witnesses, tax analysis and specialist legal representation, with responsibilities and costs agreed for that stage. Tax tribunal guidance.
What about penalties and service complaints?
A reduced claim and an inaccuracy penalty are separate questions. HMRC examines the behaviour behind an error, including whether reasonable care was taken. Careless or deliberate errors can attract penalties, and the circumstances and quality of disclosure affect the calculation. Retain evidence of how the return was prepared, checked and approved, including the instructions given to advisers. HMRC’s inaccuracy-penalty factsheet.
A complaint addresses service matters such as unreasonable delay or poor handling. An appeal addresses an appealable tax or penalty decision. A case can require both routes, with separate deadlines and payment considerations. HMRC’s complaints process.
Frequently asked questions
Does HMRC have to finish an enquiry within 12 months?
The opening window and the enquiry’s duration are different. Opening rules depend on filing history and other circumstances. Once a check is open, the questions and outstanding evidence affect how long it takes. Consider the closure procedure if progress has stalled.
Can an R&D claim be supported without detailed timesheets?
Records depend on the business and work undertaken. Explain the basis of staff allocations using the evidence available. Estimates need a reasoned, supportable method. Review the actual request with the project and finance teams before deciding what further information is needed.
Can a claim prepared by our previous adviser be reviewed?
Yes. Obtain the filed claim, working papers and correspondence so the new team can understand the position. Agree responsibilities and HMRC authority promptly while protecting existing deadlines.
Does a rejected R&D claim automatically lead to a penalty?
The penalty position requires its own assessment of the error and the behaviour behind it. Evidence of the care taken when preparing and checking the return is relevant, alongside the disclosure rules.
Can we keep using R&D relief after an enquiry?
Assess each later period under its applicable rules and facts. Record what the enquiry established and apply relevant findings to future projects, evidence and cost treatment. A previous enquiry’s outcome needs to be understood in its own context.
How does InnoFund support an R&D enquiry?
Simba Mareverwa leads InnoFund’s enquiry and dispute work. A chartered accountant and accredited mediator, his documented career includes defending more than 260 HMRC enquiries and earlier leadership of tax compliance and dispute resolution at Leyton. Read Simba’s experience.
The technical team includes Dr Jack Brent, whose qualifications include a PhD in Materials Science and a chemistry master’s degree, alongside engineering and electronics specialists. Relevant experts help examine the scientific baseline, uncertainty and project evidence while tax and financial specialists assess the rules and costs. The company’s own competent professionals remain central to explaining the work. Read Jack’s background.
Support can include a file review, case strategy, technical interviews, financial reconciliation, organised responses and agreed representation. We can work alongside an existing accountant or assess a claim prepared elsewhere. Existing enquiry cover and additional work, including legal escalation, depend on the engagement.
Bring the letter and the filed claim
Explore our R&D enquiry support service for specialist claim support, or our HMRC dispute resolution service for wider innovation-tax disputes.
Book a first conversation and flag any urgent response or appeal date.
Check the detail
Sources & scope
United Kingdom. Covers Corporation Tax and R&D enquiry principles, with wider HMRC dispute routes. Official sources checked on 17 November 2026. The relevant accounting period, scheme, filing history and actual notice determine the rules, route and deadlines. This is an InnoFund explanation and must be applied to the facts of a particular case.
This is an InnoFund explanation, not official guidance or advice on a particular claim. The facts, relevant law and applicable scheme rules must be considered together.
Sources checked: 17 November 2026. This is separate from expert sign-off.
- HMRC: Tax compliance checks
Purpose, information and outcomes of compliance checks
- HMRC: Approach to R&D tax reliefs 2023 to 2024
Risk assessment, random checks and compliance approach
- HMRC: R&D practice note CIRD80525
Payment and enquiry status
- DSIT: Meaning of R&D for tax purposes
Advance, uncertainty and project boundaries
- HMRC: Information notices CC/FS2
Formal notices and safeguards
- HMRC: Importance of a competent professional GfC3 part 3
Relevant expertise and reasoned opinion
- HMRC: Record keeping GfC3 part 5
Proportionate records and retrospective explanation
- HMRC: Check what R&D costs you can claim
Scheme and period-specific expenditure
- HMRC: Concluding enquiries COM71090
Closure notices and settlements
- HMRC: Opening enquiries COM71005
Statutory opening windows
- HMRC: Closure applications EM1976
Tribunal direction to close an enquiry
- HMRC: Appeal a tax decision
Direct-tax appeal route and usual deadline
- HMRC: Review a tax decision
Review process and tribunal notification
- HMRC: Alternative Dispute Resolution
Eligibility, sequence and mediation
- HMCTS: Tax tribunal
Independent tribunal route
- HMRC: Inaccuracy penalties CC/FS7a
Behaviour and disclosure
- HMRC: Complaints
Service complaints
- InnoFund: Simba Mareverwa CV
Career experience and qualifications
- InnoFund: Dr Jack Brent CV
Academic and professional background
